• Help

Are you a robot?

Please confirm you are a human by completing the captcha challenge below.

Verification successful. Waiting for www.sciencedirect.com to respond

• **Reference number:**a269b8dceb461877
• **IP Address:**34.96.49.132
• **User Agent:**Mozilla/5.0 (X11; Linux x86_64) AppleWebKit/537.36 (KHTML, like Gecko) Chrome/151.0.0.0 Safari/537.36
• **Timestamp:**2026-08-05 23:53:35 UTC

• About ScienceDirect
• Remote access
• Contact and support
• Terms and conditions
• Privacy policy
• Cookie settings

All content on this site: Copyright © 2026 Elsevier B.V., its licensors, and contributors. All rights are reserved, including those for text and data mining, AI training, and similar technologies. For all open access content, the relevant licensing terms apply.

",promise:n.resolve()}}}},"core/src/lib/actions/helpers/decorators/decorateNonGlobalJavaScriptCode.js":{script:function(e,t,a){"use strict";var n=a("@adobe/reactor-promise"),r=0;e.exports=function(e,t){var a="_runScript"+ ++r,i=new n((function(t,r){_satellite[a]=function(i){delete _satellite[a],new n((function(t){t(i.call(e.event.element,e.event,e.event.target,n))})).then(t,r)}}));return{code:'",promise:i}}}},"core/src/lib/actions/helpers/decorators/decorateHtmlCode.js":{script:function(e,t,a,n){"use strict";var r=a("@adobe/reactor-promise"),i=0,s={};window._satellite=window._satellite||{},window._satellite._onCustomCodeSuccess=function(e){var t=s[e];t&&(delete s[e],t.resolve())},window._satellite._onCustomCodeFailure=function(e){var t=s[e];t&&(delete s[e],t.reject())};var o=function(e){return-1!==e.indexOf("${reactorCallbackId}")},c=function(e,t){return e.replace(/${reactorCallbackId}/g,t)},l=function(e){return e.settings.isExternal};e.exports=function(e,t){var a;return l(e)&&(t=n.replaceTokens(t,e.event)),o(t)?(a=new r((function(e,t){s[String(i)]={resolve:e,reject:t}})),t=c(t,i),i+=1):a=r.resolve(),{code:t,promise:a}}}},"core/src/lib/actions/helpers/getSourceByUrl.js":{script:function(e,t,a){"use strict";var n=a("@adobe/reactor-load-script"),r=a("@adobe/reactor-promise"),i=a("../../helpers/findPageScript").byRegexPattern,s={},o={},c=function(e){return o[e]||(o[e]=n(e)),o[e]};_satellite.__registerScript=function(e,t){var a;if(document.currentScript)a=document.currentScript.getAttribute("src");else{var n=new RegExp("."+e+".");a=i(n).getAttribute("src")}s[a]=t},e.exports=function(e){return s[e]?r.resolve(s[e]):new r((function(t){c(e).then((function(){t(s[e])}),(function(){t()}))}))}}},"core/src/lib/events/helpers/pageLifecycleEvents.js":{script:function(e,t,a){"use strict";var n=a("@adobe/reactor-window"),r=a("@adobe/reactor-document"),i=-1!==n.navigator.appVersion.indexOf("MSIE 10"),s="WINDOW_LOADED",o="DOM_READY",c="PAGE_BOTTOM",l=[c,o,s],u=function(e,t){return{element:e,target:e,nativeEvent:t}},d={};l.forEach((function(e){d[e]=[]}));var p=function(e,t){l.slice(0,v(e)+1).forEach((function(e){g(t,e)}))},m=function(){return"complete"===r.readyState?s:"interactive"===r.readyState?i?null:o:void 0},v=function(e){return l.indexOf(e)},g=function(e,t){d[t].forEach((function(t){f(e,t)})),d[t]=[]},f=function(e,t){var a=t.trigger,n=t.syntheticEventFn;a(n?n(e):null)};n._satellite=n.satellite||{},n.satellite.pageBottom=p.bind(null,c),r.addEventListener("DOMContentLoaded",p.bind(null,o),!0),n.addEventListener("load",p.bind(null,s),!0),n.setTimeout((function(){var e=m();e&&p(e)}),0),e.exports={registerLibraryLoadedTrigger:function(e){e()},registerPageBottomTrigger:function(e){d[c].push({trigger:e})},registerDomReadyTrigger:function(e){d[o].push({trigger:e,syntheticEventFn:u.bind(null,r)})},registerWindowLoadedTrigger:function(e){d[s].push({trigger:e,syntheticEventFn:u.bind(null,n)})}}}}}},"adobe-mcid":{displayName:"Experience Cloud ID Service",hostedLibFilesBaseUrl:"https://assets.adobedtm.com/extensions/EP31a59fd25d824db7be52972a70e94c1c/",settings:{orgId:"4D6368F454EC41940A4C98A6@AdobeOrg",variables:[{name:"serverState",value:"%serverState%"},{name:"trackingServer",value:"metrics.elsevier.com"},{name:"trackingServerSecure",value:"smetrics.elsevier.com"},{name:"marketingCloudServer",value:"metrics.elsevier.com"},{name:"marketingCloudServerSecure",value:"smetrics.elsevier.com"},{name:"loadSSL",value:"true"},{name:"overwriteCrossDomainMCIDAndAID",value:"%mcmid - pass params%"}]},modules:{"adobe-mcid/src/lib/sharedModules/mcidInstance.js":{script:function(e,t,a,n){"use strict";var r=a("@adobe/reactor-document"),i=a("../codeLibrary/VisitorAPI"),s=a("../../view/utils/timeUnits"),o=function(e){return e.reduce((function(e,t){var a=/^(true|false)$/i.test(t.value)?JSON.parse(t.value):t.value;return e[t.name]=a,e}),{})},c=function(e){var t=n.getExtensionSettings();if("string"!=typeof t.orgId)throw new TypeError("Org ID is not a string.");var a=o(t.variables||[]),r=t.doesOptInApply;r&&("boolean"==typeof r?a.doesOptInApply=r:t.optInCallback&&(a.doesOptInApply=t.optInCallback));var i=t.isOptInStorageEnabled;i&&(a.isOptInStorageEnabled=i);var c=t.optInCookieDomain;c&&(a.optInCookieDomain=c);var l=t.optInStorageExpiry;if(l){var u=t.timeUnit;if(u&&s[u]){var d=ls[u];a.optInStorageExpiry=d}}else!0===i&&(a.optInStorageExpiry=33696e3);var p=t.previousPermissions;p&&(a.previousPermissions=p);var m=t.preOptInApprovals;if(m)a.preOptInApprovals=m;else{var v=t.preOptInApprovalInput;v&&(a.preOptInApprovals=v)}var g=t.isIabContext;g&&(a.isIabContext=g);var f=e.getInstance(t.orgId,a);return n.logger.info('Created instance using orgId: "'+t.orgId+'"'),n.logger.info("Set variables: "+JSON.stringify(a)),f.getMarketingCloudVisitorID((function(e){n.logger.info("Obtained Marketing Cloud Visitor Id: "+e)}),!0),f},l=function(e){return(n.getExtensionSettings().pathExclusions||[]).some((function(t){return t.valueIsRegex?new RegExp(t.value,"i").test(e):t.value===e}))},u=null;_satellite.getVisitorId=function(){return u},l(r.location.pathname)?n.logger.warn("MCID library not loaded. One of the path exclusions matches the current path."):u=c(i),e.exports=u},name:"mcid-instance",shared:!0},"adobe-mcid/src/lib/codeLibrary/VisitorAPI.js":{script:function(e){e.exports=(function(){"use strict";function e(t){return(e="function"==typeof Symbol&&"symbol"==typeof Symbol.iterator?function(e){return typeof e}:function(e){return e&&"function"==typeof Symbol&&e.constructor===Symbol&&e!==Symbol.prototype?"symbol":typeof e})(t)}function t(e,t,a){return t in e?Object.defineProperty(e,t,{value:a,enumerable:!0,configurable:!0,writable:!0}):e[t]=a,e}function a(){return{callbacks:{},add:function(e,t){this.callbacks[e]=this.callbacks[e]||[];var a=this.callbacks[e].push(t)-1,n=this;return function(){n.callbacks[e].splice(a,1)}},execute:function(e,t){if(this.callbacks[e]){t=(t=void 0===t?[]:t)instanceof Array?t:[t];try{for(;this.callbacks[e].length;){var a=this.callbacks[e].shift();"function"==typeof a?a.apply(null,t):a instanceof Array&&a[1].apply(a[0],t)}delete this.callbacks[e]}catch(e){}}},executeAll:function(e,t){(t||e&&!A.isObjectEmpty(e))&&Object.keys(this.callbacks).forEach((function(t){var a=void 0!==e[t]?e[t]:"";this.execute(t,a)}),this)},hasCallbacks:function(){return Boolean(Object.keys(this.callbacks).length)}}}function n(e,t,a){var n=null==e?void 0:e[t];return void 0===n?a:n}function r(e){for(var t=/^\d+$/,a=0,n=e.length;a r)return 1;if(r>n)return-1}return 0}function o(e,t){if(e===t)return 0;var a=e.toString().split("."),n=t.toString().split(".");return r(a.concat(n))?(i(a,n),s(a,n)):NaN}function c(e){return e===Object(e)&&0===Object.keys(e).length}function l(e){return"function"==typeof e||e instanceof Array&&e.length}function u(){var e=arguments.length>0&&void 0!==arguments[0]?arguments[0]:"",t=arguments.length>1&&void 0!==arguments[1]?arguments[1]:function(){return!0};this.log=ue("log",e,t),this.warn=ue("warn",e,t),this.error=ue("error",e,t)}function d(){var e=(arguments.length>0&&void 0!==arguments[0]?arguments[0]:{}).cookieName,t=(arguments.length>1&&void 0!==arguments[1]?arguments[1]:{}).cookies;if(!e||!t)return{get:Ce,set:Ce,remove:Ce};var a={remove:function(){t.remove(e)},get:function(){var a=t.get(e),n={};try{n=JSON.parse(a)}catch(a){n={}}return n},set:function(n,r){r=r||{};var i=a.get(),s=Object.assign(i,n);t.set(e,JSON.stringify(s),{domain:r.optInCookieDomain||"",cookieLifetime:r.optInStorageExpiry||3419e4,secure:r.secure,sameSite:r.sameSite,expires:!0})}};return a}function p(e){this.name=this.constructor.name,this.message=e,"function"==typeof Error.captureStackTrace?Error.captureStackTrace(this,this.constructor):this.stack=new Error(e).stack}function m(){function e(e,t){var a=ge(e);return a.length?a.every((function(e){return!!t[e]})):fe(t)}function t(){w(T),S(te.COMPLETE),b(h.status,h.permissions),o&&f.set(h.permissions,{optInCookieDomain:c,optInStorageExpiry:l,secure:p,sameSite:m}),y.execute(je)}function a(e){return function(a,n){if(!he(a))throw new Error("[OptIn] Invalid category(-ies). Please use the OptIn.Categories enum.");return S(te.CHANGED),Object.assign(T,be(ge(a),e)),n||t(),h}}var n=arguments.length>0&&void 0!==arguments[0]?arguments[0]:{},r=n.doesOptInApply,i=n.previousPermissions,s=n.preOptInApprovals,o=n.isOptInStorageEnabled,c=n.optInCookieDomain,l=n.optInStorageExpiry,u=n.isIabContext,p=n.secureCookie,m=n.sameSiteCookie,v=(arguments.length>1&&void 0!==arguments[1]?arguments[1]:{}).cookies,g=Te(i);Se(g,"Invalid previousPermissions!"),Se(s,"Invalid preOptInApprovals!");var f=d({cookieName:"adobeujs-optin"},{cookies:v}),h=this,b=ee(h),y=oe(),k=De(g),D=De(s),V=o?f.get():{},P={},E=function(e,t){return Ve(e)||t&&Ve(t)?te.COMPLETE:te.PENDING}(k,V),C=function(e,t,a){var n=be(se,!r);return r?Object.assign({},n,e,t,a):n}(D,k,V),T=ye(C),S=function(e){return E=e},w=function(e){return C=e};h.deny=a(!1),h.approve=a(!0),h.denyAll=h.deny.bind(h,se),h.approveAll=h.approve.bind(h,se),h.isApproved=function(t){return e(t,h.permissions)},h.isPreApproved=function(t){return e(t,D)},h.fetchPermissions=function(e){var t=arguments.length>1&&void 0!==arguments[1]&&arguments[1],a=t?h.on(te.COMPLETE,e):Ce;return!r||r&&h.isComplete||s?e(h.permissions):t||y.add(je,(function(){return e(h.permissions)})),a},h.complete=function(){h.status===te.CHANGED&&t()},h.registerPlugin=function(e){if(!e||!e.name||"function"!=typeof e.onRegister)throw new Error(_e);P[e.name]||(P[e.name]=e,e.onRegister.call(e,h))},h.execute=Ae(P),h.memoizeContent=function(e){Ee(e)&&f.set(e,{optInCookieDomain:c,optInStorageExpiry:l,secure:p,sameSite:m})},h.getMemoizedContent=function(e){var t=f.get();if(t)return t[e]},Object.defineProperties(h,{permissions:{get:function(){return C}},status:{get:function(){return E}},Categories:{get:function(){return ae}},doesOptInApply:{get:function(){return!!r}},isPending:{get:function(){return h.status===te.PENDING}},isComplete:{get:function(){return h.status===te.COMPLETE}},__plugins:{get:function(){return Object.keys(P)}},isIabContext:{get:function(){return u}}})}function v(e,t){function a(){r=null,e.call(e,new p("The call took longer than you wanted!"))}function n(){r&&(clearTimeout(r),e.apply(e,arguments))}if(void 0===t)return e;var r=setTimeout(a,t);return n}function g(){if(window.__tcfapi)return window.__tcfapi;var e=window;if(e!==window.top){for(var t;!t;){e=e.parent;try{e.frames.__tcfapiLocator&&(t=e)}catch(e){}if(e===window.top)break}if(t){var a={};return window.__tcfapi=function(e,n,r,i){var s=Math.random()+"",o={__tcfapiCall:{command:e,parameter:i,version:n,callId:s}};a[s]=r,t.postMessage(o,"")},window.addEventListener("message",(function(e){var t=e.data;if("string"==typeof t)try{t=JSON.parse(e.data)}catch(e){}if(t.__tcfapiReturn){var n=t.__tcfapiReturn;"function"==typeof a[n.callId]&&(an.callId,delete a[n.callId])}}),!1),window.__tcfapi}me.error("__tcfapi not found")}else me.error("__tcfapi not found")}function f(e,t){var a=arguments.length>2&&void 0!==arguments[2]?arguments[2]:[],n=!0===e.vendor.consents[t],r=a.every((function(t){return!0===e.purpose.consents[t]}));return n&&r}function h(){var e=this;e.name="iabPlugin",e.version="0.0.2";var t,a=oe(),n={transparencyAndConsentData:null},r=function(e){var t=arguments.length>1&&void 0!==arguments[1]?arguments[1]:{};return n[e]=t};e.fetchConsentData=function(e){var t=v(e.callback,e.timeout);i({callback:t})},e.isApproved=function(e){var t=e.callback,a=e.category,r=e.timeout;if(n.transparencyAndConsentData)return t(null,f(n.transparencyAndConsentData,ne[a],re[a]));var s=v((function(e,n){t(e,f(n,ne[a],re[a]))}),r);i({category:a,callback:s})},e.onRegister=function(a){t=a;var n=Object.keys(ne),r=function(e,t){!e&&t&&(n.forEach((function(e){var n=f(t,ne[e],re[e]);an?"approve":"deny"})),a.complete())};e.fetchConsentData({callback:r})};var i=function(e){var i=e.callback;if(n.transparencyAndConsentData)return i(null,n.transparencyAndConsentData);a.add("FETCH_CONSENT_DATA",i),s((function(e,i){if(i){var s=ye(e),o=t.getMemoizedContent("iabConsentHash"),c=pe(s.tcString).toString(32);s.consentString=e.tcString,s.hasConsentChangedSinceLastCmpPull=o!==c,r("transparencyAndConsentData",s),t.memoizeContent({iabConsentHash:c})}a.execute("FETCH_CONSENT_DATA",[null,n.transparencyAndConsentData])}))},s=function(e){var t=Ie(ne),a=g();"function"==typeof a&&a("getTCData",2,e,t)}}var b="undefined"!=typeof globalThis?globalThis:"undefined"!=typeof window?window:"undefined"!=typeof global?global:"undefined"!=typeof self?self:{};Object.assign=Object.assign||function(e){for(var t,a,n=1;n=0||t.indexOf("Trident/")>=0&&t.indexOf("Windows NT 6")>=0};a.getIeVersion=function(){return document.documentMode?document.documentMode:n()?7:null},a.isFirefox=function(e){return!!/Firefox/([0-9.]+)(?:\s|$)/.test(e||window.navigator.userAgent)},a.encodeAndBuildRequest=function(e,t){return e.map(encodeURIComponent).join(t)},a.isObject=function(t){return null!==t&&"object"===e(t)&&!1===Array.isArray(t)},a.defineGlobalNamespace=function(){return window.adobe=a.isObject(window.adobe)?window.adobe:{},window.adobe},a.pluck=function(e,t){return t.reduce((function(t,a){return e[a]&&(t[a]=e[a]),t}),Object.create(null))},a.parseOptOut=function(e,t,a){t||(t=a,e.d_optout&&e.d_optout instanceof Array&&(t=e.d_optout.join(",")));var n=parseInt(e.d_ottl,10);return isNaN(n)&&(n=7200),{optOut:t,d_ottl:n}},a.normalizeBoolean=function(e){var t=e;return"true"===e?t=!0:"false"===e&&(t=!1),t}})),j=(A.isObjectEmpty,A.isValueEmpty,A.getIeVersion,A.isFirefox,A.encodeAndBuildRequest,A.isObject,A.defineGlobalNamespace,A.pluck,A.parseOptOut,A.normalizeBoolean,a),=D.MESSAGES,N={0:"prefix",1:"orgID",2:"state"},O=function(e,t){this.parse=function(e){try{var t={};return e.data.split("|").forEach((function(e,a){void 0!==e&&(t[N[a]]=2!==a?e:JSON.parse(e))})),t}catch(e){}},this.isInvalid=function(a){var n=this.parse(a);if(!n||Object.keys(n).length<2)return!0;var r=e!==n.orgID,i=!t||a.origin!==t,s=-1===Object.keys().indexOf(n.prefix);return r||i||s},this.send=function(a,n,r){var i=n+"|"+e;r&&r===Object(r)&&(i+="|"+JSON.stringify(r));try{a.postMessage(i,t)}catch(e){}}},L=D.MESSAGES,x=function(e,t,a,n){function r(e){Object.assign(m,e)}function i(e){Object.assign(m.state,e),Object.assign(m.state.ALLFIELDS,e),m.callbackRegistry.executeAll(m.state)}function s(e){if(!f.isInvalid(e)){g=!1;var t=f.parse(e);m.setStateAndPublish(t.state)}}function o(e){!g&&v&&(g=!0,f.send(n,e))}function c(){r(new P(a._generateID)),m.getMarketingCloudVisitorID(),m.callbackRegistry.executeAll(m.state,!0),b.removeEventListener("message",l)}function l(e){if(!f.isInvalid(e)){var t=f.parse(e);g=!1,b.clearTimeout(m._handshakeTimeout),b.removeEventListener("message",l),r(new S(m)),b.addEventListener("message",s),m.setStateAndPublish(t.state),m.callbackRegistry.hasCallbacks()&&o(L.GETSTATE)}}function u(){v&&postMessage?(b.addEventListener("message",l),o(L.HANDSHAKE),m._handshakeTimeout=setTimeout(c,250)):c()}function d(){b.s_c_in||(b.s_c_il=[],b.s_c_in=0),m._c="Visitor",m._il=b.s_c_il,m._in=b.s_c_in,m._il[m.in]=m,b.s_c_in++}function p(){function e(e){0!==e.indexOf("")&&"function"==typeof a[e]&&(m[e]=function(){})}Object.keys(a).forEach(e),m.getSupplementalDataID=a.getSupplementalDataID,m.isAllowed=function(){return!0}}var m=this,v=t.whitelistParentDomain;m.state={ALLFIELDS:{}},m.version=a.version,m.marketingCloudOrgID=e,m.cookieDomain=a.cookieDomain||"",m._instanceType="child";var g=!1,f=new O(e,v);m.callbackRegistry=j(),m.init=function(){d(),p(),r(new I(m)),u()},m.findField=function(e,t){if(void 0!==m.state[e])return t(m.state[e]),m.state[e]},m.messageParent=o,m.setStateAndPublish=i},M=D.MESSAGES,R=D.ALL_APIS,F=D.ASYNC_API_MAP,B=D.FIELDGROUP_TO_FIELD,U=function(e,t){function a(){var t={};return Object.keys(R).forEach((function(a){var n=R[a],r=en;A.isValueEmpty(r)||(t[a]=r)})),t}function n(){var t=[];return e._loading&&Object.keys(e._loading).forEach((function(a){if(e._loading[a]){var n=B[a];t.push(n)}})),t.length?t:null}function r(t){return function a(){var r=n();if(r){var i=F[r[0]];ei}else t()}}function i(e,n){var r=a();t.send(e,n,r)}function s(e){c(e),i(e,M.HANDSHAKE)}function o(e){r((function(){i(e,M.PARENTSTATE)}))()}function c(a){function n(n){r.call(e,n),t.send(a,M.PARENTSTATE,{CUSTOMERIDS:e.getCustomerIDs()})}var r=e.setCustomerIDs;e.setCustomerIDs=n}return function(e){t.isInvalid(e)||(t.parse(e).prefix===M.HANDSHAKE?s:o)(e.source)}},H=function(e,t){function a(e){return function(a){n[e]=a,++r===i&&t(n)}}var n={},r=0,i=Object.keys(e).length;Object.keys(e).forEach((function(t){var n=e[t];if(n.fn){var r=n.args||[];r.unshift(a(t)),n.fn.apply(n.context||null,r)}}))},W={get:function(e){e=encodeURIComponent(e);var t=(";"+document.cookie).split(" ").join(";"),a=t.indexOf(";"+e+"="),n=a<0?a:t.indexOf(";",a+1);return a<0?"":decodeURIComponent(t.substring(a+2+e.length,n<0?t.length:n))},set:function(e,t,a){var r=n(a,"cookieLifetime"),i=n(a,"expires"),s=n(a,"domain"),o=n(a,"secure"),c=n(a,"sameSite"),l=o?"Secure":"",u=c?"SameSite="+c+";":"";if(i&&"SESSION"!==r&&"NONE"!==r){var d=""!==t?parseInt(r||0,10):-60;if(d)(i=new Date).setTime(i.getTime()+1e3d);else if(1===i){var p=(i=new Date).getYear();i.setYear(p+2+(p<1900?1900:0))}}else i=0;return e&&"NONE"!==r?(document.cookie=encodeURIComponent(e)+"="+encodeURIComponent(t)+"; path=/;"+(i?" expires="+i.toGMTString()+";":"")+(s?" domain="+s+";":"")+u+l,this.get(e)===t):0},remove:function(e,t){var a=n(t,"domain");a=a?" domain="+a+";":"";var r=n(t,"secure"),i=n(t,"sameSite"),s=r?"Secure":"",o=i?"SameSite="+i+";":"";document.cookie=encodeURIComponent(e)+"=; Path=/; Expires=Thu, 01 Jan 1970 00:00:01 GMT;"+a+o+s}},G=function(e,t){!e&&b.location&&(e=b.location.hostname);var a,n=e.split("."),r=t||{};for(a=n.length-2;a>=0;a--)if(r.domain=n.slice(a).join("."),W.set("TEST_AMCV_COOKIE_WRITE","cookie",r))return W.remove("TEST_AMCV_COOKIE_WRITE",r),r.domain;return""},Y={compare:o,isLessThan:function(e,t){return o(e,t)<0},areVersionsDifferent:function(e,t){return 0!==o(e,t)},isGreaterThan:function(e,t){return o(e,t)>0},isEqual:function(e,t){return 0===o(e,t)}},q=!!b.postMessage,X={postMessage:function(e,t,a){var n=1;t&&(q?a.postMessage(e,t.replace(/([^:]+://[^/]+)./,"$1")):t&&(a.location=t.replace(/#.*$/,"")+"#"+ +new Date+n+++"&"+e))},receiveMessage:function(e,t){var a;try{q&&(e&&(a=function(a){if("string"==typeof t&&a.origin!==t||"[object Function]"===Object.prototype.toString.call(t)&&!1===